St Francis Xavier shellfish shocker!

“The Miracle of Saint Francis Xavier and the Crab” is yet another painting I stumbled across that made me wonder whether my Catholic education, with all its Bible indoctrination, was really worth wearing a crown of thorns for the rest of my life. Not that Saint Francis Xavier ever figured in the Bible, of course, but in school we did get the saintly virtues hammered into our skulls, so how did I miss out on the crab episode?
This wasn’t another case of censorship, as it was with Lot’s nocturnal escapades with his daughters (see this post). No, I suspect that I was never taught about Saint Francis Xavier’s crab because he (Francis, not the crab) is the hero of the Jesuits, and the priests who decided what I should know were Franciscans or Chicagoans or something.
Probably any Jesuit-schooled person, if he’s willing to admit that much, can tell you the crab incident occurred while Francis Xavier, a high-achieving Basque missionary, optimised paradigms-wise, was furthering his mission to show Asia what a fine fellow Jesus was, much better than Muhammad or the Buddha or any of those confusing Hindu gods.

Peter Paul Rubens’ “Miracles of St Francis Xavier” from 1617-18 is at the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna. Plenty of healing and raising from the dead, but no crabs.
Having succeeded in transforming Goa on India’s west coast into a magnet for Western backpackers, Francis set sail for China in 1546. A storm came up en route to Malacca, which would become a state of Malaysia but at the time was a Portuguese outpost. The actual setting of this incident is, however, subject to a debate that would be better spent deciding whether female Catholic priests should be allowed to have abortions.
The first website Google pointed me to for an explanation of Francis and the crab was The Jesuit Gourmet, where contributor “Jhaw” relates the story and then whips up some Baked Eggplant Stuffed with Crab Meat. I’m not kidding.
“Jhaw” says Francis prayed to God to soothe the rollicking waves, and flung a cross into the water as a sacrifice. Sure enough, the storm abated.
Over at The Real Presence.org, Father John A Hardon (still not kidding) clarified that Francis didn’t toss a “cross” into the ocean, but a crucifix, so that helped.
Tourism Malacca.com quotes from “A Stroll Through Ancient Malacca” by Father Pintado to say that, no, Francis Xavier was in a small boat, just tooling around offshore, and was merely holding his crucifix over the water to calm the waves when he accidentally dropped it.
The Union of Catholic Asian News says people in Goa believe Francis was dipping his crucifix into the waves to settle them down, but it slipped from his grasp.
It’s a piddling point, but one of many disputed angles in the saga. See the rest.







Halloween was a lot more fun back in the olden days when they could make scary stuff out of such authentic materials as elephant ivory, not that the elephants ever raised any objection to plastic once it was invented.











